Wilson Whitaker Rynell

Experienced Lawyers

info@wwrlegal.com

a blue and orange check mark with the letter w on it as the Wilson Whitaker Rynell Logo
972-248-8080 DALLAS
713-830-2207 HOUSTON
512-691-4100 AUSTIN
wilson whitaker rynell attorneys and counselors at law logo
972-248-8080 DALLAS
713-830-2207 HOUSTON
512-691-4100 AUSTIN
a blue and orange check mark with the letter w on it as the Wilson Whitaker Rynell Logo

Finding Your Patent Utility, Novelty, and Non-obviousness

John Wilson • May 9, 2024

Understanding the Requirements for Patent Utility, Novelty, and Non-obviousness


Difficulties in Getting A Patent


Obtaining a patent can be a challenging process, and the success rate from filing a patent to registration is approximately 53% according to a USPTO patent issuance study. And your particular success rate can fluctuate depending on the technology field and changes in patent regulations. The patent office employs various technology centers to review specific types of patents, and these are called 'Art Units.' Art Units cover a wide range of technological areas, from biotechnology and organic chemistry to telecommunications and computer technology. Each Technology Center can have dozens of Art Units staffed by engineering and experts, reflecting the vast range of innovations that are the subject of patent applications. In addition to the high costs associated with patent filing fees, patent attorney fees, and several months or years of waiting to discover if a patent will be issued, you must first be reasonably confident your patent has utility, novelty, and non-obviousness before facing the gauntlet that is the patent prosecution process within the United States Patent & Trademark Office (USPTO).  We do recommend a patent search before you begin the patent process (see below).


What is the Utility in Your Patent?


Once of the first questions your patent attorney or patent agent will ask you is, "What utility do you see in your invention?"  The utility of a patent can be best described as its practical significance and benefit as a whole or, said otherwise, does it serve and perform a beneficial function?  For example, a painting has no utility beyond beauty of art itself.  A painting cannot be patented, but it may be copyrighted. Likewise, granting someone an exclusive patent for a worthless or useless invention is invalid because it would prevent others from making improvements or finding practical uses for it, limiting useful combinations. In a more practical sense, inventions that provide no new utility, are impractical, or solve non-existent problems are often considered unpatentable.


The United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) defines "utility" in the context of patent law as one of the requirements for an invention to be patentable. Specifically, it means that the invention must be useful or capable of providing some identifiable benefit. This concept is rooted in U.S. Code Title 35, which governs patent law:


  • Operability: The invention must work for its intended purpose. If the invention is inoperable or incapable of achieving the claimed result, it will not satisfy the utility requirement.
  • Specific and Substantial: The invention must have a specific and substantial utility, meaning it should have a real-world application and should not be frivolous or merely for amusement.
  • Credibility: The claimed utility must be credible based on the information provided in the application or generally known scientific principles.


Utility patents typically fail to meet the utility requirement when the invention fails to demonstrate a practical application, is inoperable, or is scientifically impossible, like perpetual motion machines. Additionally, patents often fail if their claimed utility is purely theoretical or speculative without practical proof, especially in fields like biotechnology or pharmaceuticals. Patent denial can also occur if your invention is against public policy, ultra-dangerous or simply illegal. So, be prepared to convincingly show your patent examiner in whichever art unit you land in evidence of the practical usefulness or 'utility' of your invention.

The requirement for utility is a requirement for a specific and real world use.  An invention must perform its intended purpose.  It is not necessary that the invention perform better than existing inventions, but it must be useful in the present day.  An increment step towards future invention or discovery will probably not satisfy the requirement.

The requirement for Novelty means that nothing (just) like it can be found in the prior art.  The most damaging prior art often comes from the inventors or owners themselves.  This may occur unintentionally as more and more proposals and presentations, believed to be to a limited audience, are published online by various hosting organizations.  In the US there is a 1 year grace period after a public disclosure by an inventor in which to file a patent.   After 1 year, the public disclosure may be used in a novelty or obviousness rejection, despite that disclosure being made by the inventor.  In most countries there is no grace period and a public disclosure becomes prior art as of the date it becomes public.

A requirement that the invention be non-obvious is a requirement that the invention be more than a logical increment improvement on what is known (35 U.S.C. §103). The USPTO considers  obviousness as viewed by a "person of ordinary skill in the art" (POSITA).  A POSITA would be the typical scientist or engineer working in the relevant field. 

What is the Novelty Requirement for a Patent?


The fundamental question in novelty is whether someone else has already invented or filed for the very thing you are trying to patent. This can include any prior patents, prior sales, prior public offers to sell, or printed publications essentially laying out or enabling your invention. Simply put, somebody has already done your patent or something very similar to it.  To be novel, an invention must be substantially different from anything else that is within the public domain.


But even if your invention is not in the public domain, it can still be anticipated and therefore, not novel.  Anticipation occurs when there is a reference or advance discussion sufficient to create a disclosure to enable or create you invention, thereby undermining its novelty. Anticipation and infringement are two sides of the same coin: that which anticipates earlier in time would infringe later in time. Peters v. Active Mfg. Co., 129 U.S. 530, 537 (1889).  You will often find that patents will disclose more than they will claim, and those disclosures can anticipate future inventions not yet filed with the USPTO.


If during patent prosecution the patent examiner finds that your invention is not novel, you may be able to amend the claims such that your invention can satisfy the novelty requirement as long as the prior art doesn't disclose every aspect of your claim(s). You need to make it unique, and your claims can be modified within the scope of your filed specifications. 


What is Patent Non-Obviousness?


Related to and building on the patent novelty requirement, non-obviousness is a requirement that a patent not only be new but also significantly different from existing knowledge or prior art. It is defined under 35 U.S.C. § 103 in the United States and means that an invention must not be an obvious improvement or combination of known inventions to a person having ordinary skill in the art (POSA). A POSA is the measuring stick by which all obviousness is measured. If a POSA would find it obvious, your patent or patent application fails.


Key aspects of non-obviousness include:


  • Standard of Obviousness: The invention should not be an evident or logical extension of existing knowledge. If a skilled person could easily deduce the invention from prior art, it will be considered obvious and not patentable.
  • Prior Art References: Examiners review existing patents, publications, and publicly available materials to determine if the invention is merely a combination of known ideas or methods.
  • Inventive Step: The invention should show an inventive step that would not be predictable based on existing technology. It should involve a leap in thinking or technology that isn't straightforward.
  • Objective Evidence: Evidence such as commercial success, long-felt needs, and recognition by experts in the field can help support the non-obviousness of an invention.
  • Combination of Prior Art: Combining different elements from prior art should not be obvious unless the combination itself leads to an unexpected or new result.


As you can see, the term nonobvious is not well defined and is somewhat amorphous. While the basic standard of what constitutes nonobviousness is 'common sense,' common sense is very elusive and differs from person to person and applicants to examiners. There are additional tests for nonobviousness, such as teaching away or hindsight rationale (evidence that someone thought it couldn't be done the way your patent does). If the prior art can be shown to teach away (go against) the combination suggested by the examiner, then this indicates that your invention may be nonobvious. Remember that your specification and your claims are the well from which you draw your claimed invention, so draft wisely, as you may need to modify and/or change claims that remain supported by your specification. 


Comprehensive Patent Search and Filing: Expert Guidance on Utility, Novelty, and Non-Obviousness


We recommend you conduct a patent search to help understand the initial problems you may face with utility, novelty, and non-obviousness. While no patent search can be fully exhaustive, it can help guide you in drafting and formulating your invention. Importantly, if your invention already exists in the public domain, then you save valuable time and money by not filing a patent.


Our patent attorneys at Wilson Whitaker Rynell are here to help you with your patents, patent applications, patent licensing, and patent litigation. Contact Us today!


  • Why is a patent search necessary before filing for a patent?

    A patent search helps to identify prior art that might be similar to your invention. By understanding existing technologies, you can better assess the novelty and non-obviousness of your idea, which are key requirements for patentability. It also aids in drafting more precise claims and reduces the risk of infringement disputes. Ultimately, it increases your chances of a successful patent application.

  • How comprehensive should a patent search be?

    A comprehensive search should cover both domestic and international patents, as well as scientific literature and non-patent sources like journals or industry publications. This helps uncover potential prior art that could affect your application. Patent search attorneys use various databases and techniques to ensure thorough coverage across various jurisdictions.

  • Can I conduct a patent search on my own?

    While you can use public databases for a basic search, professional patent search attorneys have specialized tools and expertise to conduct comprehensive searches. They are also skilled at interpreting legal language and technical specifications, ensuring a thorough evaluation of prior art that might impact your application.

  • How long does it take to complete a patent search?

    The timeline varies based on the complexity of your invention and the type of search requested. A basic novelty search might take a few days to a week, while a comprehensive search, including international databases, could take a few weeks. Your attorney can give a more precise timeline based on your specific needs.

A building with a sign that says law offices on it

Business Litigation Attorneys – Protecting Your Business in High-Stakes Legal Disputes

By John Wilson • February 12, 2025
Strategic Legal Representation for Complex Business Litigation
A woman wearing black and yellow boxing gloves is standing in a gym.

Female Divorce Attorneys in the Dallas-Fort Worth Area

By Leigh Whitaker • January 28, 2025
Female Divorce Attorneys in the Dallas-Fort Worth Area In many instances, divorce cases are challenging and emotionally taxing experiences. For this reason, it’s common for people to prefer working with an attorney of the same gender because they feel as though the attorney can empathize and understand their situation more. At the end of the day, the gender of your attorney may not affect the outcome of your case, but it’s important to feel as comfortable as possible while navigating through the process. At Wilson Whitaker Rynell, our experienced female divorce attorneys offer compassionate and empathetic approaches while they develop a comprehensive legal strategy to represent you. Why Should You Choose a Female Divorce Lawyer? There are many reasons why hiring a female divorce attorney can help you throughout your divorce. For one, they often have experience working on issues that disproportionately affect women in divorce such as spousal support (alimony), child custody disputes, and asset division. Additionally, female divorce lawyers offer a unique level of empathy, understanding, and communication. As a result, many clients feel that they are more approachable and compassionate, which is beneficial when dealing with the emotional turmoil of the process. More importantly, female divorce attorneys are more familiar with how the court treats women in divorce cases and use this knowledge to strategically protect their clients’ interests, whether male or female. Why Our Female Divorce Attorneys May be Right for You At Wilson Whitaker Rynell, our female divorce attorneys are skilled, knowledgeable professionals, they also have many years of experience in handling complex divorce cases. Whether it’s issues surrounding custody of children, alimony, or asset division, our female divorce lawyers ensure each client receives high-quality legal advice. Our firm’s female divorce attorneys provide the highest level of personal attention, ensuring that each client’s unique needs and concerns are addressed through every step. Unique Challenges Women Face in Family Law Disputes in Texas Family law disputes can be emotionally charged and legally complex, especially for women navigating the process in Texas. Women often encounter unique challenges due to their roles in the marriage and family dynamic, particularly when it comes to child custody, child support, and the division of marital assets. Child Custody Challenges In many marriages, women take on the primary caregiving role for their children. However, when it comes to custody decisions, courts in Texas prioritize the best interests of the child over parental gender. While this often works in favor of mothers, women may still face hurdles in proving they are better suited to provide the stable environment the child needs, especially if their ex-spouse disputes custody. Factors such as work schedules, living arrangements, and financial stability can come under scrutiny. Child Support Issues While Texas law allows women to seek child support, collecting these payments can sometimes prove difficult. Women awarded child support may find themselves dealing with ex-spouses who delay payments, make partial payments, or refuse to pay altogether. Enforcing child support orders often requires legal intervention, which can add to the emotional and financial strain. Division of Marital Assets In Texas, a community property state, marital assets are typically divided equitably during divorce. Women who are awarded assets such as the family home may face challenges related to maintaining the property, refinancing a mortgage, or covering associated expenses. Additionally, women who sacrificed their careers to support their spouses or raise children may feel disadvantaged during the division of assets if their earning potential is limited compared to their ex-spouse. How Your Divorce Attorney Will Support You Each divorce case is unique, and having an experienced attorney standing by you is vital. Whether you’re dividing assets, negotiating child custody, or managing other complex legal issues, the female divorce attorneys at Wilson Whitaker Rynell are here to protect the interests of you and your family. Our attorneys will take the time to understand your unique circumstances and empower you to make informed decisions that support your career, family and future. When you choose a female divorce attorney from Wilson Whitaker Rynell, you can trust that they will: Prioritize your family’s best interests. Negotiate with integrity, ensuring fairness and transparency. Clearly explain all your options and their potential outcomes. Help you create the future you want by offering trusted legal advice. Use efficient methods to minimize unnecessary costs and keep the process manageable. Navigating family law disputes requires a thorough understanding of Texas family law and strong advocacy. Women facing divorce or other family law issues are encouraged to seek an experienced family law attorney who can provide personalized guidance. A skilled lawyer can help craft a strategy that protects their rights and ensures a fair resolution. This includes representing their interests in court, negotiating settlements, and helping enforce orders such as child support or spousal maintenance.
A man riding a horse with a bull behind him

Wrangling Writs of Execution in Texas

By John Wilson • January 23, 2025
Understanding Writs of Execution in Texas: A Layperson’s Guide If a court determines that someone owes money to another party, the debtor—referred to as the "judgment debtor"—typically has 30 days to pay off the debt. If the debt remains unpaid after this time, the creditor, or "judgment creditor," can take legal action to enforce the payment through a Writ of Execution . This legal process, governed by Texas law, enables creditors to collect what they are owed by seizing and selling the debtor’s non-exempt assets. What Is a Writ of Execution? Under Texas Rules of Civil Procedure 629 , a Writ of Execution is a court order that authorizes a sheriff or constable to seize the debtor’s property to satisfy the debt. This writ is an essential tool for creditors when voluntary repayment has not occurred. Once the writ is issued, it is handed over to a county constable or sheriff, who is required to act “without delay” in collecting the debtor’s real and personal property. The seized property is then sold, and the proceeds are used to pay off the debt. If multiple writs are filed against the same debtor, the assets are distributed in the order the writs were received. What Property Can Be Seized Under a Writ of Execution? Texas law is very specific about which types of property can and cannot be seized to satisfy a judgment. Exempt Property Certain assets are protected from seizure under Texas Property Code § 41.001. These include: The debtor’s homestead (primary residence) Wages earned from employment Professionally prescribed health aids Workers’ compensation benefits College savings plans Some insurance benefits Personal property valued up to $50,000 for individuals and $100,000 for families Unique to Texas, the law also protects items like family Bibles, two firearms, pets, and for rural residents, livestock (e.g., 12 head of cattle and 120 fowl). This extensive list reflects Texas's cultural heritage and values. Non-Exempt Property Assets that are generally not exempt include: Vacation homes Timeshares Pleasure boats Airplanes Jewelry exceeding certain value thresholds The specific procedures for seizing different types of property are detailed in Texas Rules of Civil Procedure 639 . Can a Writ of Execution Be Avoided? Judgment debtors have a few options to avoid the execution of a writ: Filing a Supersedeas Bond A supersedeas bond can temporarily halt enforcement of the writ. This bond, filed with the county clerk or justice of the peace, preserves the status quo while the debtor seeks further legal remedies. This option is governed by Texas Rules of Civil Procedure 634 . Challenging the Execution Debtors can file a claim for wrongful execution in situations such as: The debt has already been paid Exempt property is being seized The levy is excessive Additionally, courts take extra care to protect property classified as a homestead under Texas Property Code § 41.002(c) . When only one spouse is responsible for the debt, Texas Family Code § 3.202(a) and related provisions provide guidance on levying against community or separate property. The Role of County Officials in Executing the Writ Once the writ is issued, its enforcement falls on county officials, typically a sheriff or constable. These officials must act in accordance with Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 34.072 , which requires them to execute the writ and report back to the court. They must: Give proper notice of the sale of seized property Ensure the proceeds are appropriately delivered to the creditor Avoid overstepping legal boundaries, such as seizing exempt property Failing to execute the writ properly can result in serious consequences, where a sheriff’s refusal to levy on a property initially listed as exempt (but later deemed abandoned) led to court action and damages awarded to the creditor. Preventing Fraudulent Transfers One challenge creditors face is when debtors attempt to hide or transfer assets to avoid collection. To address this, Texas follows the Uniform Fraudulent Transfer Act under Tex. Bus. & Comm. Code § 24.001 et seq .. This act provides legal remedies to creditors when a debtor’s transfer of assets is deemed fraudulent. Effect of a Defendant's Death on Writs of Execution Under Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 34.072 , the death of a defendant after a writ of execution is issued halts execution proceedings. However, any lien acquired from the writ's levy is still enforceable by the county court when paying off the deceased's debts. Why Proper Execution Of The Writ Is Crucial The rules for filing and serving a Writ of Execution are strict and detailed. Missteps, such as filing the writ in the wrong county, failing to serve the proper parties, or missing key deadlines, can lead to delays or even render the writ ineffective. Both creditors and debtors must ensure compliance with these rules to avoid unnecessary complications. For creditors, failure to properly enforce the writ could mean losing the opportunity to collect on a judgment. For debtors, not responding appropriately to a writ could result in the loss of valuable assets, even those that might have been exempt.
A sign that says jct 17 texas on it

The Intersection of Venue Selection & Motions to Dismiss in Texas

By John Wilson • January 17, 2025
Understanding Venue Selection and Motions to Dismiss in Texas Civil Litigation
A man and a woman are holding a sign that says `` our first home ''.

Wraparound Mortgages in Texas - Seller Home Finance

By John Wilson • January 17, 2025
Wraparound Mortgages in Texas and The Pros and Cons of Seller Financing
A judge is writing on a piece of paper next to a gavel on a wooden table.

Appealing a JAMS Arbitration Judgement

By Chelsea Lankford • December 6, 2024
Appeals Through JAMS Arbitration: A Structured Approach to Review 
A woman in a black hoodie is making a stop sign with her hand.

Texas Court is Halting the Corporate Transparency Act

By Kayla Holderman • December 6, 2024
How One Texas Court is Halting the Corporate Transparency Act
A red balloon is sticking out of a window of a blue wooden building.

How to Revive Abandoned Trademarks

By Chelsea Lankford • November 15, 2024
How to Revive an Abandoned Trademark Application with the USPTO
A notebook is open to a page that says do n't compare yourself to others

Use of Third-Party Trademarks in Competitive Advertising: A Legal Guide

By John Wilson • November 5, 2024
Navigating the Use of Third-Party Trademarks in Competitive Advertising: A Legal Guide
Show More
The Wilson Legal Group are Dallas attorneys that specializes in Patents, Trademarks, Copyrights, Trade Secrets, Complex Litigation, Business/Corporate Law, Family Law and Real Estate Law. At the Wilson Legal Group, our clients are our focus. Our philosophy is simple and straight-forward: Understand our clients' needs, hopes, and interests in order to help them flourish. Our staff strives to build strong relationships with our clients in order to appreciate their best interests and help them achieve their goals.

Request A Blog?

Have an idea for a blog?  Click and request a blog and we will let you know when we post it!

Share by: